Should A Trader Measure Profits In Percentages, Pips, Or Risk/Reward (R)?

Forex trading plan4

In the world of trading, being able to calculate profits precisely is crucial for traders to assess their performance, make wise decisions, and efficiently manage risk. The subject of how to calculate profits does, however, come up frequently, leaving traders to think about other approaches like percentages, pips, or the risk/reward ratio (R). The decision comes down to personal preference and trading strategy because each of these methods has advantages and disadvantages of its own. In this article, we will discuss the primary means of measuring profits, including the “2%” method, measuring pips or points, and measuring based on risk/reward “R”. Additionally, we will discuss the myth of compounding and the 2% rule, the differences between fixed risk and % risk, and so on. Traders can better understand which strategy might be the most appropriate for their particular trading goals and circumstances by looking at the characteristics of percentages, pips, and the risk/reward ratio.

The Three Primary Means of Measuring Profits:

Accurate profit measurement is crucial in the dynamic world of trading so that traders can assess risk, evaluate their performance, and make wise decisions. Profit measurement techniques give traders insightful information about the results of their trades, enabling them to assess their performance and improve their tactics. The three main ways to calculate trading earnings are as follows:

  1.     The “2%” Method: The “2%” strategy is a well-liked technique that traders employ to control risk and calculate earnings. With this approach, each trade’s risk exposure is capped at 2% of the trading capital. Traders try to protect their capital and lessen the effects of prospective losses by following this rule. By offering a consistent and impartial framework for assessing trading success, the “2%” technique also serves as a key method of quantifying earnings. To analyze and evaluate their returns throughout several trades and periods, traders base their profit calculations on a proportion of their trading capital. Using this method, traders can evaluate the success of their tactics and make changes as necessary. The “2%” strategy also encourages careful risk management, preventing traders from taking unwarranted risks that can endanger their entire trading balances. The “2%” technique is a useful tool for traders to attain long-term profitability and sustainability in their trading endeavors since it combines smart risk management with profit monitoring. 
  2.     Measuring Pips or Points: Pips and points are frequently measured in trading to describe price changes and determine gains and losses. The smallest incremental change in the price of a trading tool is measured in pip, often referred to as a point in some markets. Traders can evaluate their wins or losses in a standardized and objective manner by quantifying profits in pips or points. By offering clear and accurate statistics for assessing trading success, this technique serves as a significant method of monitoring profits. Traders can compare and analyze their profitability by tracking it across several trades and timeframes. By measuring gains in pips or points, traders can more precisely establish their profit goals and control their risk. Trading professionals can evaluate prospective earnings and choose the right stop-loss and take-profit levels by understanding the value of each pip or point and taking into account variables like position size. Overall, calculating gains in pips or points gives traders a useful and trustworthy method to assess their trading performance and make wise judgments. 
  3.     Measuring based on “R” or Fixed $ Risk: A typical risk management method used by traders is measuring earnings based on “R” or fixed dollar risk. This strategy entails figuring out how much a trader is willing to risk in a single transaction, which is often expressed as a percentage of their trading capital or as a set dollar amount. Traders can evaluate the possible return on the level of risk involved by evaluating profits in terms of risk. By giving a thorough overview of a trade’s risk-to-reward ratio, this method serves as a significant tool for calculating profits. By comparing the possible return to the initial risk, it enables traders to assess the profitability of their deals. Profits are measured in “R” or fixed dollar risk, which aids in effective risk management and enables traders to choose trade entries, stop-loss levels, and profit objectives after doing their research. It makes sure that deals are examined regarding both risk exposure and potential gains. Traders can more accurately evaluate the overall effectiveness and success of their trading methods by including the concept of risk in profit measurement.

The Myth of Compounding and the 2% Rule

In trading circles, compounding and the 2% Rule are frequently misunderstood. One widespread misconception is that compounding by itself ensures exponential wealth development. While compounding can increase profits over time, it necessitates constant profitability and is impacted by elements like market circumstances and risk management. The 2% Rule is the subject of another urban legend that purports to guarantee success. While keeping risk to 2% for each transaction is a reasonable strategy, it cannot ensure success and must be used in conjunction with a solid trading plan. Furthermore, trading calculators are not always believed to be accurate profit forecasters. Trading calculators are tools that rely on precise inputs and suppositions, but they can help with risk evaluation and position sizing. While using trading calculators might be useful, it’s also important to exercise critical thinking and gain a thorough understanding of the underlying market dynamics. Dispelling these fallacies and highlighting the necessity for a comprehensive strategy in the pursuit of trading success, successful trading requires thorough analysis, risk management, and responding to market dynamics.

How much should you Risk per trade?

Choosing the right risk level for each trade is important, especially for traders using a demo account. A demo account offers a risk-free setting where traders can hone their trading techniques without risking their own money. It is crucial to handle risk management carefully throughout this learning phase. It is normally preferable to use the demo account as if it were a live trading account, even though the specific risk per trade may vary depending on the trader. This entails using reasonable risk parameters and adopting effective risk management strategies. By doing this, traders can form healthy routines and build important expertise in effective risk management. It’s critical to keep in mind that the knowledge gained from managing risk in a trial account may be used directly in real trading, where protecting cash and controlling risk is of utmost importance.

Fixed Risk vs. % Risk

There are two different ways to manage risk in trading: fixed risk and % risk. The distinctions between fixed risk and % risk are as follows:

  • Fixed Risk entails setting a certain dollar amount to risk on each trade, regardless of the size of the account or the outcome of the trade. On the other hand, % Risk entails risking a portion of the value of the trading account with each trade.
  • Fixed Risk offers a dependable and uncomplicated methodology, ensuring that the trader’s risk exposure stays constant. % Risk enables the risk level to change following the size of the account, possibly decreasing risk as the account gets bigger or raising it during drawdowns.
  • For traders who want a more controlled and predictable approach to risk management, fixed risk is a good option. Traders who want their risk exposure to be commensurate with the size of their account and adaptive to shifting market conditions frequently prefer % Risk.

The decision between Fixed Risk and % Risk ultimately comes down to the trader’s particular preferences, trading style, and risk tolerance.


In conclusion, calculating trading profits is an essential part of assessing performance and coming to wise conclusions. The choice ultimately depends on the trader’s objectives, trading strategy, and risk management preferences. There are numerous techniques available, including percentages, pips, and risk/reward ratios (R). The advantages and disadvantages of each approach should be taken into account by traders, who may also want to combine some of them to get a more complete picture of their trading performance. Traders can better analyze their gains and optimize their tactics for long-term performance by selecting the most appropriate measuring method and implementing proper risk management.